Conciliation is often viewed as one of the few straightforward aspects of the Sexual Harassment at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) (POSH) Act, 2013. Since it is a voluntary mechanism designed to facilitate a mutually acceptable settlement, many assume that once both parties agree to resolve the matter, the Internal Committee’s (IC) role is complete.
However, as discussed in Episode 20 of Anvay Insights, led by Adv. Divya R, Trainer & External Member, The Legal Swan, the reality is often far more nuanced. Through a case study, the session explored how changing facts, evolving allegations, and questions of jurisdiction can complicate what initially appears to be a simple conciliation.
The Case: When Conciliation Isn’t So Simple
The discussion centred around a complaint arising out of a personal relationship between two colleagues. The complainant alleged blackmail, threats, and harassment after refusing the respondent’s marriage proposal. Instead of opting for a formal inquiry, she requested conciliation, stating that her objective was to secure peace of mind, prevent future interference, and ensure her personal photographs and information were not misused.
As the conciliation process progressed, both parties negotiated settlement terms, including:
- Undertakings to refrain from contacting each other or their respective families.
- Commitments to delete photographs, videos, and personal data.
- Assurances against future intimidation, harassment, or misuse of personal information.
The case illustrated how the IC’s role during conciliation extends beyond simply documenting an agreement. It must facilitate fair, voluntary discussions while ensuring both parties understand and consent to the proposed terms.
When the Story Changes
Fresh Allegations Surface
Just when the settlement terms were close to being finalised, the complainant sought to withdraw the complaint altogether. Around the same time, she introduced new allegations, including claims of physical assault and wrongful restraint that had not formed part of the original complaint.
This shifted the discussion from settlement to a more fundamental question:
Can an IC simply close a complaint because the complainant wishes to withdraw it?
The session highlighted that such developments require the IC to carefully reassess the matter rather than mechanically accepting the withdrawal.
Jurisdiction Comes First
As discussions continued, additional facts emerged regarding the parties’ relationship, family involvement, and events that extended beyond the workplace.
These disclosures prompted the IC to examine whether the dispute genuinely fell within the scope of the POSH Act or whether it was primarily a personal dispute between two individuals.
The session emphasised that while the POSH Act addresses workplace sexual harassment, it is not intended to adjudicate every disagreement between colleagues. Personal relationship disputes, family conflicts, caste-related issues, and allegations that lack a sufficient workplace nexus may fall outside the IC’s jurisdiction and require recourse through other legal forums.
Confidentiality Doesn’t End With Conciliation
Another important takeaway from the session was the continuing obligation of confidentiality throughout the POSH process.
The case demonstrated that despite being instructed not to discuss the complaint outside the proceedings, both parties continued sharing developments with a common acquaintance. This eventually came to the IC’s attention and formed part of its findings.
The discussion reinforced that confidentiality is not merely a procedural formality. It is an ongoing responsibility that applies throughout the proceedings, including during conciliation.
Key Learnings for Internal Committees
The session concluded with several practical reminders for IC Members:
- Assess jurisdiction before facilitating conciliation. Not every dispute involving employees falls within the scope of the POSH Act.
- Recognise that facts may evolve. Fresh allegations or new disclosures can significantly alter how a complaint is assessed.
- Withdrawal is not always the end of the matter. The IC must understand the circumstances before deciding how to proceed.
- Actively enforce confidentiality. Parties must be reminded that confidentiality obligations continue throughout the process.
- Process matters. Even where the IC ultimately concludes that a complaint falls outside its jurisdiction, conduct during the proceedings may still warrant observations or recommendations.
Looking Beyond Settlement
The session served as a valuable reminder that conciliation is not simply about helping parties reach an agreement. It requires IC Members to balance empathy with procedural fairness, remain alert to changing facts, and clearly understand the limits of their jurisdiction.
By examining a realistic and evolving case study, the discussion encouraged participants to think beyond the mechanics of settlement and focus instead on ensuring that every stage of the POSH process is handled with fairness, diligence, and legal clarity.
